Thursday, July 3, 2014

Homologous and Analogous Traits.

Homologous Traits.

1A.) A venus fly trap- a plant that lives in swampy parts of the southeastern part of the US and is known for snapping and trapping bugs and digesting them, and a pitcher plant, whose leaves have been modified as a 'pitcher' to catch insects to digest.

1B.) The leaves of these two plant species. In a venus fly trap, the 'jaw' is the leaves of the plant that is used to trap and digest insects because those insects have the nitrogen and phosphorous that the soil lacks in the parts of the states where they are found. In pitcher plants, which can be found in most parts of canada, use their 'leaves' to catch insects and sometimes even larger prey (even snakes!). 

1C.) The common ancestor between the two would be the Drosera, which is essentially a sticky fly paper that uses it's leaves to capture insects by having them fly into their leaves and 'sticking' the bugs to their leaves and digesting them from there. 

1D.) 



Analogous Traits.

1A.) Penguins and a a fish.

1B.) The fins in each species- penguins are land and water based mammals who use their flippers to walk and to swim when in water as well and look more like claws than fins. Penguin fins are webbed, which allows them to walk on land as well as swim fast in the waters. Fish are specifically water animals, and their fins were developed in a way to allow them to glide them through the waters more easily. Fish also have many variations of fins in their body- they have dorsal fins, pectoral fins, pelvic fins, etc. Each specific fin was evolved to fit the needs of the fish to safely swim and live in the water.

1C.) I could not find a common ancestor, being that penguins are mammals and fish are sea creatures.

1D.)



1 Comments:

At July 4, 2014 at 12:31 PM , Blogger L Rodriguez said...

Your homologous pairing was very creative and interesting! Good logic in your explanation. The only correction is the "Drosera" is a living genera and not an ancestor and they are all sundews. But you are correct that these two species probably did arise from a common ancestor that had an early version of this approach to carnivory, which is unique in plants.

Good comparison in your analogous trait, but let's address your conclusion in the section on ancestry. In the guidelines, there is a statement that says:

"All pairs of organisms share some common ancestor if you go back far enough in time. "

This is true for the fish and the penguin as well, but do you need to know if the ancestor had the trait to confirm that these are analogous traits? We know that the penguins "fin" is a derived wing. It is not something they inherited from their bird ancestor, so they could not have inherited it from the much more distance common ancestor with the fish, correct? That was the question here and what you needed to provide as evidence that these two traits are definitely analogous.

Other than the point on ancestry, good post.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home